Blade Size

To begin, the blade size will matter. That’s because the bigger the blade, the fewer teeth it will have.

The Hegner has a 22-inch blade that is large enough to handle any project.

On top of that, it can cut through various materials at almost any speed you desire.

Thanks to the built-in Quicklock tension release system, cutting becomes easier than ever.

Whether you are working with woods, metals, or even acrylics, the blade is large, durable, and leaves some pretty smooth edges.

In short, there’s a good chance you won’t need to use any sandpaper afterward.

Excalibur

The Excalibur scroll saw features a 16-inch blade.

This is the kind of blade you’ll need to make your smaller projects a lot easier to do.

If you are more of a hobbyist who uses softwoods or plywoods, odds are you might find this blade size to be worth it.

Since it’s a smaller blade, you’ll get more teeth, as well.

So, as far as precise cuts are concerned, the Excalibur might be precisely what you’re looking for.

Plus, you’ll get nice smooth edges without a single hint of splintering as a result.

The Winner

While both blades perform fast, clean cuts with ease, the Hegner wins out in the size department.

They also operate at variable speeds, but the Hegner has a slightly higher top speed than the Excalibur.

When it comes to size and speed, the choice is clear.

While it’s a photo finish, the Hegner edges out against the Excalibur due to its ability to go a bit faster and still make the same precise cuts (and with more materials, as well).

Power Feature

Aside from the size of the blade, how the device is powered matters, as well.

Hegner

The Hegner scroll saw is runs via an AC plug.

This means you plug it into the wall and get consistent amounts of power no matter how long you use it.

Since it runs on electricity, a battery will obviously not be needed.

It can handle even the most tedious jobs, so the power usage will stay the same. Plus, you won’t worry about a loss of power over time.

For this reason, it makes this saw a lot more effective in terms of performance.

Excalibur

The Excalibur scroll saw is battery-operated. This opens up a wide variety of possibilities. For one, it would be easy to carry around.

If portability is what you want in a scroll saw (and yes, it’s possible), then this will be your obvious choice.

With a lack of power outlets depending on where you work, that won’t be a problem.

The major drawback of battery-powered tools is that it does lose power over time. When they do, that’s when its effectiveness starts to wane.

This means you’ll end up having to charge it for a short period to preserve the level of power to where the saw can be at its most effective.

With that in mind, this is mostly built for shorter projects that basically last the weekend.

The Winner

Both have excellent power sources.

Each option has its own advantages and disadvantages, but both are effective when at full power.

At this point, you might choose between one or the other, depending on personal preference.

You might need something powered by an outlet, or you prefer one with a long-lasting battery. Either way, we’ll call it a draw here.

Warranty

The warranty that comes with any product tells you how confident the manufacturer is about its longevity and durability.

Hegner

Hegner’s variable speed saw comes with a manufacturer’s warranty that covers you for seven years.

In the event of any defects or other issues, the saw can be replaced without costing you an arm and a leg.

Warranties that last this long give you an indication of how long the saw itself usually lasts.

A scroll saw should last years, even decades (like most power tools). The only things that may need replacing over time are the blades.

The lifespan will depend on many factors, including the type of blades you use and the kind of materials you are cutting through.

Excalibur

The Excalibur scroll saw has a two-year limited warranty.

When the words “limited” come to mind, you know that it will cover some things and won’t cover other incidents, like neglect or intentional damage or abuse.

If you are considering the idea of purchasing the Excalibur scroll saw, be sure to find out more about what the warranty will cover.

Most of the time, warranties will cover defects or instances where the saw will fail due to a malfunctioning part.

Winner

The Hegner has a more extended warranty. And from what we’re seeing, it might have more coverage of specific incidents compared to the Excalibur scroll saw.

If you are looking for a longer warranty, then the choice is obvious.

Still, there may be instances where the warranty may be voided before it even expires, so keep that in mind, too.

Size

The size of the scroll saw you pick will depend on the projects you plan on using it for.

Hegner

While we couldn’t find the exact measurements at this time, some users have stated that the Hegner is small in size.

This is a good sign if you want something that will be easily portable.

Then again, it might be bothersome for someone who might want to cut larger pieces of wood.

Excalibur

The Excalibur measures 27 inches (width) by 15 inches (depth) by 17 inches (height).

It’s a pretty sizeable saw compared to its Hegner counterpart.

Winner

Gathering what we know, the Excalibur beats out the Hegner in terms of size.

It’s slightly larger but has the smaller blade nonetheless.

If dimensions matter to you, then the Excalibur could be exactly what you need.

The faster the blade is, the better it will cut through the material. This is why it is another factor that you need to keep in mind.

Hegner

The variable speeds for the Hegner range from 400 to 1,700 RPM.

At these faster speeds, it can actually do a better job at cutting hardwoods, such as maple or oak (assuming you have installed durable enough blades to handle them).

Excalibur

At its lowest, the Excalibur starts out at 400 RPM. The fastest it can go is 1,400 RPM.

Still, it’s relatively fast for those who want to cut through thicker and possibly harder pieces of wood.

Winner

In terms of maximum speed, the Hegner will take the checkered flag in this “speed race” versus Excalibur.

Again, the faster the blade goes, the better. Plus, you can get projects done a lot quicker if you can cut through wood faster.

Final Recount

Hegner: 4 out of 5 sections

Excalibur: 2 out of 5 sections

As you can see, the Hegner will win in the battle between the two in terms of how they perform.

The Excalibur is awarded a point for the draw in the power department and takes another point as being larger in dimension size.

Pros and Cons of Each